Comparison Of Top 4 Pool Heating Options: Heat Pumps Are Exceptional.
Understanding the available pool heating options is essential for the home owner. Designed to keep your pool’s water at optimum temperatures, these heaters often operate for long periods of time and run up your utility bill. There are four main options to choose from here for most pool owners.
1.Gas Pool Heating Options: Only favorable for small pools and spas, but needs gas source and complicated installation, not safe.
For a larger pool, the cost associated with a gas pool heater is extreme. These heaters will require gas each time they heat up the water and in cases where the pool itself isn’t used routinely enough, leaving the system running will prove to be costly. As a solution that isn’t energy efficient, it comes as no surprise these units are not environmentally friendly and with an overall life span of just five years, they need to be routinely replaced.
On the flip side, these units do have a few benefits associated with them including:
- Heating is based on water temperature, not air temperature
- Low investment for those on a tight budget
- Will heat up the water extremely fast
Gas heaters can be combined with another form of heating such as solar heating and can work well as a “booster”.
Gas heaters require access to a gas source. This means there needs to be pipes run to the heater and a source for them to connect to. It is important to anticipate installation costs into the mix if you are considering this method.
2. Heat Pumps are an Exceptional Pool Heating Choice
Heat pumps are another option for pool heating you need to consider. These pumps require a power source be available and they pull air into the pump and run it over a compressor and air is then sent to the base of the pool to heat it up. This design allows a consistent temperature no matter what the weather is like outside and they provide warmer water than other heaters on the market.
There are some pros and cons to these heating options for pools. The benefits include:
- Lower operating costs
- Energy efficient option that is environmentally friendly
- Units last about 10 years
- Don’t need the sun to warm the water
This doesn’t mean there are no disadvantages. The informed homeowner needs to understand these pumps also have:
- Slow heating times (than gas), so you need to plan in advance
- Higher unit purchase costs
- A need for temperatures to be above 10°C to operate properly
- Can be expensive to operate
3. Roof Based Solar Heating Panels Cut Costs
This is a popular option in Southern Europe or Australia. You install solar collector arrays (panels or black tubes) on the roof. Pool water is then run through these and returned to the pool. This allows the water to be heated through the power of the sun and it makes them an effective choice in most cases. However, on rainy days and at night, the water is no longer heated and during the colder months, you might not be able to use the pool without an alternative heating source.
Fortunately, there are some great benefits including:
- Low annual operating costs
- Little to no maintenance required
- Most environmentally friendly option
- Longer lifespan than other heaters.
For the environmentally savvy individual, these pool heaters are the ideal choice for the home.
You may also check our article Solar Pool Heating – The Complete Buyers Guide for an in-depth review on this pool heating option.
4. Solar Pool Covers are The Most Effective Solutions Available
There are quite a few people who will agree solar covers are among the most effective options you have. They cost nothing to operate and they are relatively inexpensive to purchase. When the cover is over the top of the pool, the cover will begin to absorb the sunlight and transfer it into heat with the insulation and trap the heat in the area surrounding the pool. This causes the heat to transfer to the water for incredible results.
When properly installed, you can count on a few benefits with this heating option:
- Water is kept warmer, increasing as much as 8°C
- Evaporation will be minimal reducing water waste
- Chemicals won’t be as quickly depleted maximising their effectiveness, while minimising the cost
- Work even better when combined with other heating systems
Just keep in mind that installing a solar pool blanket can be tricky. While manual options do roll up, you have to take the time to remove them and place them back on the pool for use. Automatic solutions can make this easier, but their installation can be costly and for many this cost is prohibitive.
Each of the four options have their own unique sets of pros and cons. It is important to weigh your options and determine which of these heater types will meet your needs, within the budget you have available.